A Stranger in the Crowd
A few weeks ago I was at Speaker’s Corner in Hyde Park, a place where crowds have regularly gathered for the past 200 years to watch people debate and preach, and that day was no different, as there was a sizeable crowd present, most likely due to the good weather. On the outskirts of the chaos, I noticed a man standing alone on a step-ladder away from the noise, giving a speech to no one. People walked past him as if he didn’t exist, some even looked at him with mockery, as if he were a lunatic, without even hearing what he had to say. Just a few feet away, a man with a thick American accent dressed as a cowboy accompanied by a man wearing a very eye-catching halloween mask and holding up a provocative sign had drawn a crowd of well over a hundred people. No one cared if they were speaking nonsense; they knew what the crowd wanted and they gave it to them.
But that man standing alone? He might have been speaking the most sense out of everyone there. He could have shared something life changing, but no one stopped to listen. Why? Because he didn’t play the game. He didn’t wear a costume, hold a sign, or stir the pot for attention. He didn’t try to fit in. He had come, perhaps, to speak about something he believed in deeply. But because he didn’t conform to the entertainment-driven crowd, no one gave him a chance.
That image stuck with me, and it was a reflection of what it means to be a practicing Muslim in a western workplace. The one who refuses to compromise is often like that man; resolute and principled but invisible to those who are drawn to the loudest, flashiest personalities. And just like that man could’ve easily put on a mask and said something outrageouss to gain attention, the believer too could don a mask to integrate, blend in, laugh at the inappropriate jokes, attend the parties, and nod along with ideologies they don’t believe in, but instead they choose the lonely path; one that was perfectly explained by Layth ibn Sa’d who said:
من لم يشعر بالغربة فليس على السنة
“Whoever does not feel a sense of strangeness [among the people], then he is not upon the Sunnah.”
This invaluable statement teaches us that the one who holds his ground must accept the price: isolation, dismissal, and quiet exile, because the truth, when spoken without compromise, rarely gets you in with the crowd.
A Profitless Trade
As a Muslim who has spent the last few years working in the corporate world, I’ve seen the quiet toll the modern working environment can take on our īmān (faith). They never mention in the job description that succeeding in these roles requires compromising the very principles that define us as Muslims, and that climbing the career ladder requires far more than just compromise. I’ve watched Muslim colleagues bend over backwards just to fit in; sacrificing their religious identity for a shot at success that rarely comes. I didn’t want to make this post too anecdotal, but within the past few years alone I’ve seen a Muslim colleague miss Salāt al-Jumu’ah (the obligatory Friday prayer) every single week without fail to go to the pub with other colleagues, even though we made it clear to him how dangerous his decision was, and offered to take him with us multiple times. I’ve also seen a Muslim take up the position of leading the ‘prevent’ program within my workplace, a role which has pushed the persecution and harassment of countless Muslims. Isn’t it ironic that his career ambitions led him to oversee a system known for targeting his own people?
I’ve also sat alone downstairs eating lunch while every Muslim in my office joined the team for a christmas party upstairs; their attendance raising further question marks on my decision to decline the invite. It was at that same company that I even faced the unexpected sting of an appraisal where I was told I don’t “mingle enough with the team” which was corporate code for not chatting by the printer or joining the Friday pub runs. Worst of all, I’ve watched people utterly unfit for promotions sail past others who were much more deserving; their only qualifications being a knack for socialising and brown-nosing management. The modern day office has become a crucible for Muslims where their faith is tested, and too often, it’s the soul that loses.
It’s sad enough seeing these fellow Muslims crumble under the weight of the office environment, but those same Muslims who fold make it harder for those who refuse to compromise. When a Muslim colleague attends the christmas lunch or goes to after work dinners, they set a precedent. Management starts to expect it from everyone. “If they can do it, why can’t you?” becomes the unspoken question. My choice to eat alone downstairs is no longer just a personal stand, it’s suddenly a rebellion against a norm that other Muslims helped establish. So when they happily promote Ribā based products or laugh and joke with the opposite gender, they signal to the office that Muslims can, and should, conform. Suddenly, my refusal to dilute my beliefs is “unreasonable” in the eyes of a manager who’s seen others cave without any resistance.
Worse still, their compromises prop up a system that rewards assimilation over merit. The corporate machine doesn’t take your faith into consideration. It demands conformity, starting with the expectation of free-mixing with the opposite gender, with men and women sitting shoulder to shoulder in meetings and share casual banter in the lunch room. This may be seen as a harmless situation to some, but it becomes a constant test of boundaries for the resolute Muslim who risks being labeled unfriendly or uncooperative, so they compromise, shaking hands they’d rather not, making small talk they’d rather avoid, all to keep the peace and stay in the game. Then come the after-hours tests; christmas parties, birthday celebrations, and “team-building” events. To constantly skip them is to indicate that you’re not a “team player”, a stab in the heart for career advancement. The unwritten clause in those ‘optional’ invites is that it’s also a loyalty test. Are you one of us or not?
That Muslim who chose the role with ‘Prevent’ didn’t just climb the ladder, he built a new rrung on it for others to follow, proving that success comes to those who conform to the office culture, not those who stay true to what they believe in, even if they go above and beyond in their role. Meanwhile, those who hold firm; praying on time and skipping the pub, get painted as outcasts, harder to promote because they don’t fit the mold that the more liberal Muslims helped cast. Every handshake with the opposite gender, every party invite they accept, tightens the screws on those who refuse to compromise, making their path not just lonelier but far steeper.
Some Heights aren’t Meant to be Reached
We need to realise that as Muslims, we face an unspoken choice: either climb the career ladder or cling to our faith. Yahyā ibn Muʿādh رحمه الله said:
النّاس ثلاثة:
فرجُل شغله معاده عن معاشه؛ فتلك درجة الصالحين،
ورجُل شغله معاشه لمعاده؛ فتلك درجة الفائزين
ورجُل شغ معاشه عن معاده؛ فتلك درجة الهالكين.
“People are of three types:
1. A man whose concern for his Hereafter distracts him from his worldly life; that is the rank of the righteous.
2. A man whose worldly life serves his Hereafter; that is the rank of the successful.
3. And a man whose worldly life distracts him from his Hereafter; that is the rank of the doomed.”
So ask yourself; which group do you fall under? Have you ever sinned to fit in? Were you able to stop yourself from joining in when others laughed and joked with female/male colleagues? For some reading this, these examples may seem like exaggerations which ‘aren’t that deep’, and some may see them as normal workplace interactions, when in reality they are an erosion of our religious identity, a compromise of principles that chips away at the soul without us realising until it’s too late. This is something the Prophet ﷺ warned us against over 1400 years ago when he said:
يَأْتِي عَلَى النَّاسِ زَمَانٌ، لاَ يُبَالِي الْمَرْءُ مَا أَخَذَ مِنْهُ أَمِنَ الْحَلاَلِ أَمْ مِنَ الْحَرَامِ””
“A time will come when one will not care how he gains his money, from halal (means) or haram.” (Sahih al-Bukhari, 2059)
We need to realise that Islām is not just restricted to personal acts of worship like prayers and fasting, it is a complete way of life, covering everything from the battlefield to the bathroom. So how can we justify setting aside our faith the moment we step into the workplace? Once we understand the encompassing nature of Islām , we can no longer excuse religious compromises, no matter our profession. It won’t matter how many patients we treated or how much money we raised for charity, if those deeds involved disobedience to Allah, their value may be lost in the hereafter when they matter most. This is what differentiates us from the Sahāba. Yes, they worked as we do, but their hearts were always anchoredf in the remembrance of Allah, as Qatada said:
وَقَالَ قَتَادَةُ كَانَ الْقَوْمُ يَتَبَايَعُونَ، وَيَتَّجِرُونَ، وَلَكِنَّهُمْ إِذَا نَابَهُمْ حَقٌّ مِنْ حُقُوقِ اللَّهِ لَمْ تُلْهِهِمْ تِجَارَةٌ وَلاَ بَيْعٌ عَنْ ذِكْرِ اللَّهِ، حَتَّى يُؤَدُّوهُ إِلَى اللَّهِ.
“The people used to buy and sell and engage in trade; but whenever they had to perform any of Allah’s obligations, then neither trade nor sale distracted them from the remembrance of Allah until they had fulfilled that obligation (to Allah).” (Sahih al-Bukhari)
Their mindset in every aspect of life was centred around Allah and His religion, not just whilst they were in the masjid or narrating ahādith. So if you think it is absolutely necessary for you to stay in your job whilst committing these sins then remember you’ll have to justify that before Allah, the One who created you only to worship Him alone. And never forget:
مَا عِندَكُمْ يَنفَدُ وَمَا عِندَ اللَّهِ بَاقٍ وَلَنَجْزِيَنَّ الَّذِينَ صَبَرُوا أَجْرَهُم بِأَحْسَنِ مَا كَانُوا يَعْمَلُونَ
“Whatever is with you will end, and whatever is with Allah will remain. And those who are patient, We will certainly pay them a reward in proportion to the best of what they used to do.” (Surah An-Nahl, 16:96).
So remain patient even if it means you have to suffer financially or socially, and remember that whatever you are compromising your religion for, it is incomparable to what Allah has in store for you if you give it up for His sake.
To those who say ‘it’s not that deep’, I’d say the compromise runs deeper than just social gatherings. To fit in, Muslims have to water down their beliefs. The modern workplace has become a breeding ground for progressive, liberal ideas like LGBT rights, gender fluidity, women’s ‘liberation’, and any hint of traditional Islamic views will result in anonymous complaints and a one way ticket to HR. A Muslim who dares to voice unease about same-sex relationships or affirm distinct roles for men and women is ostracised and branded a bigoted dinosaur unfit for modern society, so silence becomes the safest option, but even that silence has to be an agreeable one because any sign of disagreement and you’re out of the crowd. Even the hijāb (which includes clothing, not just a headscarf), an Islamic symbol of devotion and modesty, becomes a fashion statement, so most will trade it for less ‘confrontational’ styles, or abandon it entirely to blend into the corporate uuniform. Beards slowly become shorter and shorter until shaving becomes a regular part of the daily routine, each swipe of the razor incurring the acceptance of colleagues and the Anger of Allah. Allah warns us:
وَلَا تَشْتَرُوا بِعَهْدِ اللَّهِ ثَمَنًا قَلِيلًا إِنَّمَا عِندَ اللَّهِ هُوَ خَيْرٌ لَّكُمْ إِن كُنتُمْ تَعْلَمُونَ
“And do not exchange the covenant of Allah for a small price. Verily what is with Allah is better for you if only you knew.” [Surah An-Nahl, 16:95].
So how could we possibly trade our faith for the acceptance of those who will never truly accept us?
The sacrifices pile up. Prayers squeezed into lunch breaks or crammed together and ‘combined’ at home. Speaking out against harām financial practices like Ribā (usury) or dishonesty with customers marks you as naive, a troublemaker who doesn’t undrstand how business works. Islām becomes a burden that’s bad for business rather than a guiding light to live by.
And for what? The bitter irony is that most who bend over backwards, who trade their deen for a seat at the table, don’t even win. The promotions they crave, the ones dangled like carrots to justify every compromise, often go to those wwho never had to wrestle with their faith to fit in, and were easier to accept as one of them. Years of rushed prayers and awkward small talk at harām gatherings amount to nothing but a stagnant job title and the occasional pat on the back, watching others overtake them. The ladder they’ve climbed turns out to be a treadmill; .tiring and taking them nowhere.
Was it worth it?
To the Muslim who traded their religion for a hopeful shot at success, ask yourself, was it really worth it in the end?,Faith, once the priority in your life, has been reduced to an inconvenient shadow, trailing behind until it eventually disappears in the darkness you’ve plunged yourself into. The promotions fade, the applause dies, but the regret will remain forever. Pay attention to the golden advice of the Salaf, such as al-Kathīr b. Ziyād who said:
بيعوا دنياكم بآخرتكم تربحونها والله جميعاً
ولا تبيعوا آخرتكم بدنياكم فتخسرونهما والله جميعاً.
“Sell your worldly life for the sake of the Hereafter and by Allah, you will attain both!
But do not sell the Hereafter for the sake of this worldly life, for by Allah, you will lose both!”
[Dhamm al-Dunyā, #269]
So to those who are still early on in their careers, my sincere advice to you is: don’t throw away an eternal crown in pursuit of a worldly one. No promotion can replace the reward of holding fast to your faith.
Solutions
“الصبر شجرة جذورها مرَّة وثمارها شهية”
“Patience is a tree; its roots are bitter, and its fruits are delicious.”
The path to preserving our faith in an environment dictated by those who look down upon our beliefs as archaic will undoubtedly involve hardships, but these trials are the bitter roots that yield eternal rewards. The Messengers before us endured mockery, harm, and even death, yet their steadfastness always resulted in divine victory, as Allah reminds us:
وَلَقَدْ كُذِّبَتْ رُسُلٌ مِّن قَبْلِكَ فَصَبَرُوا عَلَىٰ مَا كُذِّبُوا وَأُوذُوا حَتَّىٰ أَتَاهُمْ نَصْرُنَا
“And certainly were messengers denied before you, but they were patient over [the effects of] denial, and they were harmed until Our victory came to them” [Surat al-An’ām 6:34]
For those of you who have sincerely pondered over your situation and have decided you would be unable to stay in your current work setting without compromising and cannot pay the price of being ostracised, there is still hope. Muslims today can’t deny that we have many practical options to uphold our faith while earning a living, and I would argue it’s never been easier.
Taking up remote roles or transitioning to fields like technology makes it a lot easier to avoid conflicts over workplace culture. The more difficult alternative is starting your own business, which not only helps you to avoid the toxicity of a workplace but also gives you control over your time, making it easier to schedule your day around the daily prayers.
It goes without saying that these alternatives also come with their challenges and it’s not an easy decision to make; it may require sacrificing your degree or years of experience gained in a particular field, or even accepting a lower salary, but that is when a believer’s patience is truly put to the test.
Take inspiration from someone I know personally, a qualified optometrist who, at the start of a promising career, left a high-paying role because it involved unavoidable khalwa (being in isolation with a non-mahram). After years of studying at university and sitting numerous exams post-graduation, it was their trust in Allah’s plan and firm adherence to His religion that guided them to prioritise the pleasure of their Creator over their own aspirations and the expectations of family and friends. If this person can make such a courageous choice, what’s holding you back from doing the same? Don’t justify staying in a job that conflicts with Islam just because you have fooled yourself into thinking it is a necessity. Instead, we need to accept our deficiencies and be inspired by those who were stronger than you and I. Those who had the courage to leave behind years of hard work out of fear of Allāh. Take it as a challenge and an opportunity to grow closer to Him, and be certain that if you can make it past the bitter roots of patience keeping in mind the sweetness of its fruits, then Allah will undoubtedly grant you provisions and opportunities that you could never have imagined. As a poet once said:
كما ان بعد الليل فجرا
سيكون بعد الصبر نصرا
”Just as after the night comes dawn,
after patience will come victory.”
Stranger Thoughts // أفكار غريبة 
Leave a comment